Afrika_SFB-FRA90px-AAfrika_SFB-FRA90px-AAfrika_SFB-FRA90px-AAfrika_SFB-FRA90px-A
  • Home
  • Project Design
  • Projects
  • Team
  • Research Regions
    • Kenya (KRV)
    • Tanzania (SAGCOT)
    • Namibia (KAZA)
  • Publications
  • Events
  • Video Gallery

Reflections on global north south partnerships

  • Home
  • CRC Newsletter_ The Digest Issue 2
  • Reflections on global north south partnerships

An illustration image of two individuals meeting. Image courtesy of Freepic

Triggered by the worldwide protests against police violence and the related debates against structural forms of discrimination that unfolded after the violent killing of George Floyd in the Unites States of America, members of the CRC started a discussion on academic partnerships in the context of North-South research projects. Questions about how to establish horizontal collaborations in such international research projects are central to this debate.

To further the discussion, the CRC invited Dr. Vanessa Thompson (European University Viadrina, Frankfurt, Oder) to moderate an online workshop on 12 October this year. Vanessa Thompson has a background in Philosphy and Sociology and a focus on critical studies, with special attention to racism and migration. She is an expert on post- and decolonial feministic theories.

The workshop started with a talk by Vanessa Thompson, titled “Exiting the comfort zone and entering the contact zone: postcolonial-feminist ethnographies between self-reflexivity and anthropology of postcolonial power relations.” In her presentation, she provided a number of concepts from the field of postcolonial studies, that may be applied to examine research collaborations. Most notably, Vanessa Thompson suggested to understand academia and the research realm, especially within the context of research projects in which researchers of the Global North engage with their colleagues in the Global South, as a postcolonial ‘contact zone’: A social space, “[…] where cultures meet, clash and grapple with each other, often in contexts of highly asymmetrical relations of power, such as colonialism, slavery, or their aftermaths as they are lived out in many parts of the world today.” (Pratt 1991: 34)

Departing from this conceptualization a couple of points derive, along which such North-South research collaborations can be evaluated: (1) Has horizontal research collaboration between scholars from the North and their colleagues from the Global South been established? (2) Has it been considered what matters to the people one works with? (3) Are research findings being disseminated among the partners, stakeholders and the studied communities? (4) Has research been carried out in a self-reflexive manner? (5) Are the research results accessible to the scientific and local communities in the research countries?

The subsequent discussion, that unfolded at the workshop, was structured along two lines. On the one-hand, the CRC and its research partnerships were examined and points for improvement of the collaborations were identified. On the other hand, general, structural hindrances to the establishment of horizontal research collaborations were recognized.

Especially with regard to the formulation of a proposal for the continuation of the CRC, the workshop participants found it useful and important to evaluate the first funding phase along the above-mentioned points: where did the CRC succeed to establish horizontal research partnerships and where did it fail to do so, and why? When it comes to the design of the research questions, this could be done together with partners, already defining their role in the research plan. The CRC has already developed strategies in order to assure better integration of its partners, and is actively making its findings available to researchers worldwide. While these efforts should be stressed, there is also room to further develop equal research partnership in the context of the collaborative research centre.

Structurally, the CRC – much as other third-party funded research projects in the Global North – grapples with hurdles that impede horizontal collaboration. In countries of the Global North, funding for projects that work in the Global North is often part of a larger development agenda, that might be at odds with the independent development of scientifically relevant research topics. Moreover, the bureaucratic processes that research collaborations are involved in at universities in the Global North as much as at partner institutions in the South, make the establishment of partnerships at times cumbersome. Research collaborators often find themselves rendered as service providers, rather than equal academic partner. Lastly, at least in Germany, there are currently no ethical standards against which research in and with the Global South is measured against. While approval of the research proposal by ethical review committees is in fact mandatory, a specific evaluation of the establishment of North-South research partnerships is still lacking.

Especially with the current travel restrictions in times of the global COVID-19 outbreak, research partnerships are crucial to any project that works across the North-South divide. In this context, the workshop with Vanessa Thompson offered a valuable perspective on scientific research collaborations, not only for the CRC. Preparing the proposal for the second funding phase, we are already incorporating some of the ideas that developed out of the workshop.

Reference:

Pratt, ML 1991, Arts of the Contact Zone. Profession 1991: 33-40.

0
Share
Tracy Kariuki
Tracy Kariuki

Related posts

February 1, 2023

[Video] Prof. Javier Revilla Diez: The Growth Corridor Vision and its Realities – Insights for Development in Africa


Read more
January 25, 2023

CRC-TRR Public Lecture: Katrin Böhning-Gaese


Read more
January 24, 2023

Pastoralism in Development: Free Online Course International Institute for Environment and Development


Read more

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

four × three =

https://youtu.be/-n5NYGU7RZA?t=5

TWITTER FEED

Future Rural AfricaFollow

Future Rural Africa
CRC228Future Rural Africa@CRC228·
1 Feb

#CRCTRR228 researcher Javier Revilla Diez (C01) on mobilizing natural assets, #Livelihood impact and Future prospect of #WBNLDC development corridor @CanadaBlanchLSE

https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=BPg7g7ksGMs

CRC Project C01➡️https://bit.ly/3HNxTjF

@UniCologne @UniBonn @dfg_public

Reply on Twitter 1620766329447002112Retweet on Twitter 1620766329447002112Like on Twitter 16207663294470021125Twitter 1620766329447002112
CRC228Future Rural Africa@CRC228·
30 Jan

More info & abstract
➡️ https://bit.ly/3DpTvAc

Future Rural Africa@CRC228

📅 SAVE THE DATE📅
Mon | Feb 6, 2023 | 16:15 – 17:45 CET @UniCologne

Katrin Böhning-Gaese:

From nature conservation to social-ecological systems

#CRCTRR228 Public Lecture Series:

Reply on Twitter 1620061072828039168Retweet on Twitter 16200610728280391682Like on Twitter 16200610728280391685Twitter 1620061072828039168
Retweet on TwitterFuture Rural Africa Retweeted
dannenberg_pPeter Dannenberg@dannenberg_p·
28 Jan

Liebe alle, auch von @Follmann_Alex @GeoMFranz und mir gibt es eine Session beim DKG in Köln:
Nachhaltigkeit und Resilienz von Lieferketten in Krisenzeiten
https://dkg2023.de/sitzungen/nachhaltigkeit-und-resilienz-von-lieferketten-82652

Reply on Twitter 1619269106519408640Retweet on Twitter 16192691065194086408Like on Twitter 161926910651940864018Twitter 1619269106519408640
Load More...

QUICK NAVIGATION LINKS

  • Vacancies
  • CRC Reads
  • CRC Lecture Series
  • The Digest: Future Rural Africa Editorial Newsletters
  • Podcast
  • Bridging Concepts
  • News Archive
  • Notes from the field
  • Conference Reports

GENDER BOARD

  • Gender

BRIDGING CONCEPTS

  • 0
    #African time: Streamlining the future to make it legible
    November 24, 2020
  • 0
    Far-reaching connections and inoperable crossings
    October 27, 2020

2 + 19 =

MEMBERS SITE

Click here

TRR228 DATABASE

Click here

CONTACT US

Click here
© 2018 Future Rural Africa | Collaborative Research Center 228       Impressum   Datenschutz